On her blog, Michelle Malkin summarizes her latest column thusly:
My latest column blasts the "good" leak/"bad" leak and "whistleblower"/"felon" memes now being used by the Left to defend the NYT/NSA story. To the Times' defenders, keeping secrets to protect counterterrorism operations is an impeachable offense, but keeping secrets to protect the Gray Lady's fanny is an elite media prerogative.
It would be fair to point out that "the Right" in general, and Malkin in particular, are playing both sides of the "PlameGate versus NSAGate" street as well ... if that street existed. But it doesn't. There's no comparison between the "outing" of Valerie Plame and the revelation of the Bush administration's illegal domestic espionage program. Here's why:
- Regardless of whether or not the Plame "outing" violated the specific statute on revealing the identity of a "covert agent," a grand jury did conclude that it involved the disclosure of classified information. If that finding is material to the case against Scooter Libby, his attorneys may, of course, attempt to rebut it.
- No grand jury, applying Executive Order 12958, could reasonably conclude that the existence of Bush's "warrantless eavesdropping" program is, or legally ever could be, "classified information." Not no way, not no how.
Here's the relevant section:
Sec. 1.8. Classification Prohibitions and Limitations.
(a) In no case shall information be classified in order to:
(1) conceal violations of law, inefficiency, or administrative error;
(2) prevent embarrassment to a person, organization, or agency;
(3) restrain competition; or
(4) prevent or delay the release of information that does not require protection in the interest of national security.
Here's the New York Times article which started the ball rolling.
What are the distinguishing characteristics of the program which are revealed in the article?
1) That it was conducted extra-legally; and
2) that public disclosure of its extra-legality would embarrass the President of the United States.
That's it. That's all. The article does not reveal the name of the program. It does not reveal the names or positions of the persons conducting the program. It does not reveal sources. It does not reveal methods. It does not reveal heretofore unknown capabilities. It reveals only those characteristics of the program which are intrinsically unclassifiable. And if something is not classifiable, it is by definition not classified.
The disclosure of the program's existence and its criminal nature did not damage the national security; it only damaged the president's reputation. It did not endanger the United States; it only endangered the president's ability to continue committing crimes with impunity. If there's any parallel between the Plame case and this one, that parallel is to be found in the Bush administration's continuing insistence that it is above the law. To their everlasting shame, Malkin and friends' political raison d'etre seems to have become defending that insistence at all costs.
--
Technorati Tags: News, Current Affairs, Current Events, Politics, Michelle Malkin
Icerocket Tags: News, Current Affairs, Current Events, Politics, Michelle Malkin
Wednesday, January 04, 2006
Tuesday, January 03, 2006
Telling the future(s)
The question on my mind when I dropped by InTrade -- a "prediction markets trading exchange" -- was "is the US going to go to war with Iraq in the near future?" The rumor simmers up and down, and anecdotally it's up a bit this week. I figure the equivalent of an online political casino (and don't let anyone tell you that futures trading is anything but gambling with a more respectable name) is the best place to get odds.
InTrade futures for "USA and/or Israel to execute an overt Air Strike against Iran by 30June06" are trading at $12US; $27US for it to happen by the end of 2006; and $31.50US for it to happen by the end of March, 2007. For purposes of comparison:
- "Osama Bin Laden to be captured/neutralised by 30 June 2006" is trading at $7.40US.
- "Abu Musab al-Zarqawi to be captured/neutralised by 30 June 2006" is trading at $18.10US.
- "Sen John McCain to be the Republican Presidential Nominee in 2008" is trading at $29.60US.
- "Hillary Clinton to be the Democratic Presidential Nominee in 2008" is trading at $45.00US.
So I guess we could say it is more likely that the US or Israel will bomb Iran than that Osama or Zarqawi will take a dirt nap, or that John McCain will get the GOP nomination, but less likely than that Hillary will get the Democratic nomination. If the futures traders are knowledgeable and trading on the basis of their most rational assessments of the facts, of course.
I'm not buying or selling any futures, of course. And I can't tell you whether or not war with Iran is in the offing. If I had to guess, I'd guess that the Bush administration is just waiting for (or trying to bring about) circumstances which give it a plausible excuse. That's a pretty high bar right now, given the failures in Afghanistan and Iraq. There's precisely zero chance of it being a "march on to the next victory" move. It has to be a "regrettable, urgent necessity" move instead.
I wouldn't be terribly surprised if the US or Israel detonated a "dirty bomb" on Iranian soil and then advertised the explosion as being "proof" of an Iranian nuclear weapons program which is "much further along than we suspected." Nor would I be surprised if a major terror attack on US soil was blamed on Iran (regardless of its actual source). Either of those might do the trick. Or not. Americans have (correctly) grown more cynical about their government's honesty and motives over the last few years.
Why do I think the Busheviks want to tangle with Iran so badly? It's simple: Having irretrievably lost two wars in four years (and not doing so well on the general "war on terror," either), the only chance the War Party has to climb back up to a reasonably respectable place in history is to turn what they've falsely advertised as a "generational war for survival" and "World War IV" into the real thing.
If things are allowed to continue on their present course, the US eventually will eventually slink home as Iraq falls apart and/or falls completely into Iran's orbit, and Afghanistan slides back into its perpetual tribal warfare with the Taliban about as ascendant as it was before we came (which is not much more ascendant than it is now).
On the other hand, if the Busheviks can ignite a bona fide world war, there's some chance that 60 years from now Afghanistan and Iraq will be related to 9/11 as Wake Island and Bataan were to Pearl Harbor -- early, hopeless, necessary defeats instead of stupid, pointless defeats. And, of course, a more general/conventional war would make it easier to "mobilize the nation" (i.e. enslave the young through conscription and the rest of the country through industrial "direction for the war effort"). It's also going to take one king-hell change of fortunes for the GOP to retain control of the House of Representatives this year, and of the Senate and White House in 2008. A "big" war is a big gamble, but the Republicans are running low on cheap tricks, so why not bet it all on that kind of roll?
Yep. Cynical old me. Hope I'm wrong.
InTrade futures for "USA and/or Israel to execute an overt Air Strike against Iran by 30June06" are trading at $12US; $27US for it to happen by the end of 2006; and $31.50US for it to happen by the end of March, 2007. For purposes of comparison:
- "Osama Bin Laden to be captured/neutralised by 30 June 2006" is trading at $7.40US.
- "Abu Musab al-Zarqawi to be captured/neutralised by 30 June 2006" is trading at $18.10US.
- "Sen John McCain to be the Republican Presidential Nominee in 2008" is trading at $29.60US.
- "Hillary Clinton to be the Democratic Presidential Nominee in 2008" is trading at $45.00US.
So I guess we could say it is more likely that the US or Israel will bomb Iran than that Osama or Zarqawi will take a dirt nap, or that John McCain will get the GOP nomination, but less likely than that Hillary will get the Democratic nomination. If the futures traders are knowledgeable and trading on the basis of their most rational assessments of the facts, of course.
I'm not buying or selling any futures, of course. And I can't tell you whether or not war with Iran is in the offing. If I had to guess, I'd guess that the Bush administration is just waiting for (or trying to bring about) circumstances which give it a plausible excuse. That's a pretty high bar right now, given the failures in Afghanistan and Iraq. There's precisely zero chance of it being a "march on to the next victory" move. It has to be a "regrettable, urgent necessity" move instead.
I wouldn't be terribly surprised if the US or Israel detonated a "dirty bomb" on Iranian soil and then advertised the explosion as being "proof" of an Iranian nuclear weapons program which is "much further along than we suspected." Nor would I be surprised if a major terror attack on US soil was blamed on Iran (regardless of its actual source). Either of those might do the trick. Or not. Americans have (correctly) grown more cynical about their government's honesty and motives over the last few years.
Why do I think the Busheviks want to tangle with Iran so badly? It's simple: Having irretrievably lost two wars in four years (and not doing so well on the general "war on terror," either), the only chance the War Party has to climb back up to a reasonably respectable place in history is to turn what they've falsely advertised as a "generational war for survival" and "World War IV" into the real thing.
If things are allowed to continue on their present course, the US eventually will eventually slink home as Iraq falls apart and/or falls completely into Iran's orbit, and Afghanistan slides back into its perpetual tribal warfare with the Taliban about as ascendant as it was before we came (which is not much more ascendant than it is now).
On the other hand, if the Busheviks can ignite a bona fide world war, there's some chance that 60 years from now Afghanistan and Iraq will be related to 9/11 as Wake Island and Bataan were to Pearl Harbor -- early, hopeless, necessary defeats instead of stupid, pointless defeats. And, of course, a more general/conventional war would make it easier to "mobilize the nation" (i.e. enslave the young through conscription and the rest of the country through industrial "direction for the war effort"). It's also going to take one king-hell change of fortunes for the GOP to retain control of the House of Representatives this year, and of the Senate and White House in 2008. A "big" war is a big gamble, but the Republicans are running low on cheap tricks, so why not bet it all on that kind of roll?
Yep. Cynical old me. Hope I'm wrong.
Monday, January 02, 2006
BlogProps: Performancing.Com
I haven't made any secret of the fact that I want to make money as a blogger (and I do -- not big money, yet, but money). Among the sites dedicated to the notion of "blogging for dollars," Performancing.Com has proven itself the most useful (for example, Performancing is where I learned about the little tchotchke that pulls up a graphic preview when you hover over one of my Amazon links).
No hype here -- just facts, tools and reasonably well-informed musings and speculations. I've found it useful -- if you want to "monetize" your blog, I suspect you will as well.
Of course, there's a broader topic here. I've tried to ensure that Kn@ppster is a fun place to be, and to weave the commercial activity into the natural flow, rather than letting it dominate. I figure that a large archive of interesting, pertinent stuff is a better sales tool than an "ad blog" ... not to mention a whole lot more fun to write, and worth writing whether it's making money or not. But ... am I getting it right? Comments, please.
No hype here -- just facts, tools and reasonably well-informed musings and speculations. I've found it useful -- if you want to "monetize" your blog, I suspect you will as well.
Of course, there's a broader topic here. I've tried to ensure that Kn@ppster is a fun place to be, and to weave the commercial activity into the natural flow, rather than letting it dominate. I figure that a large archive of interesting, pertinent stuff is a better sales tool than an "ad blog" ... not to mention a whole lot more fun to write, and worth writing whether it's making money or not. But ... am I getting it right? Comments, please.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)