A Bit of a Contradiction ...

A few hours ago, I saw someone arguing both of the following two points in close order:

1. "Derek Chauvin didn't kill George Floyd, George Floyd died of coincidental heart attack or possibly a drug overdose!"
2. "If George Floyd had just complied with Derek Chauvin's orders, he'd still be alive!"

Seems to me you kind of have to pick one of those two.